Morgan County Superior Courtroom Decide Brenda Trammell rejected what is often a routine request by an area authorities to validate a bond settlement, ruling Thursday that the event authority that introduced the case hadn’t proved that the $5 billion plant, projected to rent 7,500 folks, was “sound, cheap and possible” as is required underneath state legislation.

Trammell additionally dominated that underneath state legislation, Rivian needs to be required to pay common property taxes due to its stage of management over property it could be leasing from the event authority, undermining the explanation that the authorized motion was introduced within the first place.

Rivian declined to remark.

The Georgia Division of Financial Growth and an area four-county joint improvement authority that recruited Rivian mentioned they had been “dissatisfied and respectfully disagree with Decide Trammell’s resolution. They mentioned they aren’t giving up on their plans, and are contemplating an attraction.

“We stay undeterred in our efforts to convey high-paying, American manufacturing jobs to Georgia, and are presently assessing all authorized choices,” the teams mentioned.

The Irvine, California-based electrical automobile producer introduced final 12 months that it could construct the ability on a 2,000-acre (800-hectare) website in Morgan and Walton counties about 45 miles (70 kilometers) east of Atlanta alongside Interstate 20. It plans to supply as much as 400,000 autos a 12 months there. Rivian, which additionally has a plant in Regular, Illinois, had hoped to interrupt floor as early as this summer season and start manufacturing in 2024.

By sustaining possession of the property and leasing it to Rivian, native governments would exempt Rivian from a projected $700 million in property taxes over 25 years, though Rivian has agreed to make $300 million in funds in lieu of taxes through the interval.

The property tax break is a key a part of the $1.2 billion in tax breaks and incentives that Georgia and native officers supplied for Rivian to construct a plant within the state.

The long-used maneuver circumvents a ban in Georgia’s state structure on giving “gratuities” to corporations or people. If Trammell’s order requiring regular property taxes is upheld, it may name different massive tax breaks into query and maintain officers from utilizing the instrument sooner or later.

The state additionally plans to spend $200 million to purchase the location and put together it. Rivian may declare a projected $200 million earnings tax credit score, and $280 million in gross sales tax breaks on equipment and development supplies. The state additionally plans to spend $90 million to construct a job coaching middle and prepare staff.

The decide discovered persuasive the arguments of a bunch of native residents who oppose improvement of the plant, saying it’ll spoil their high quality of life in a rural space that Atlanta’s sprawl is now encroaching upon.

“It is rather fulfilling that we native residents had been in a position to band collectively to take action a lot analysis in an effort to convey a fantastic authorized staff on board and ship us unbelievable outcomes like these,” mentioned JoEllen Artz, president of opposition group Morgan Land, Sky & Water Preservation. Artz and different opponents intervened within the lawsuit to query the appropriateness of the tax break deal proposed by a four-county joint improvement authority that helped recruit Rivian.

The corporate has encountered difficulties in ramping up manufacturing in Illinois and its as soon as hovering inventory worth has tumbled with some key traders dumping shares.

Trammell wrote that native and state officers appeared to not have thought of the upper prices of providers that native governments would incur, or whether or not Rivian had the cash to finish the undertaking.

“Rivian’s money reserves are shortly drying up, thus casting critical doubt on whether or not it is going to be in a position to begin, not to mention full, the undertaking,” Trammell wrote.

Join the Fortune Options electronic mail record so that you don’t miss our greatest options, unique interviews, and investigations.