Unlock the Editor’s Digest Absolutely Free for Exclusive Insights
Roula Khalaf, the esteemed Editor of the Financial Times, handpicks her favorite stories in this engaging weekly newsletter.
Global creditors of Evergrande are urgently seeking a last-minute agreement to prevent a court order that would lead to the liquidation of the heavily indebted Chinese property developer. This situation has escalated as stakeholders understand that a formal insolvency could be initiated at any moment, greatly diminishing their prospects for recovering investments. The ongoing discussions reflect the creditors’ intent to explore various restructuring strategies to avert drastic financial outcomes.
In recent days, investors holding Evergrande’s debt have been actively engaging with the company regarding multiple restructuring options, as two sources familiar with the discussions revealed. The urgency of these talks has intensified, particularly with the Hong Kong High Court set to hear a petition from a creditor, Top Shine Global, on Monday. This petition seeks the winding-up of Evergrande, which collapsed in 2021 under a staggering $300 billion in liabilities, underscoring the high stakes involved in these negotiations.
According to insiders acquainted with the ongoing negotiations, creditors have been exerting increasing pressure on Top Shine to withdraw its legal action. Such a move could pave the way for restructuring discussions that might include proposals for debt-to-equity swaps, enabling creditors to retain a stake in the company’s future. However, Top Shine’s legal representatives did not respond immediately on Sunday, and efforts to obtain comments from Evergrande itself have been unsuccessful.
Evergrande has been at the epicenter of China’s real estate crisis, a situation that has brought to light the extensive challenges facing the entire sector, which once accounted for a significant portion of the nation’s economic growth. The ramifications of Evergrande’s financial troubles are profound, highlighting issues of over-leverage that have permeated the broader real estate market, impacting numerous developers and creating instability in the financial landscape.
Creditors representing several financial institutions have previously cautioned that Evergrande’s potential liquidation could have a “catastrophic effect” on other developers in China. Such an outcome could severely hinder the ability of Chinese companies to raise capital in global financial markets, amplifying concerns about a broader economic downturn resulting from the real estate sector’s struggles.
In the wake of Evergrande’s default, many other developers have encountered similar difficulties, as Chinese authorities have implemented measures aimed at curbing excessive borrowing within the property market. The situation has led to a ripple effect, causing widespread challenges for various stakeholders in the industry as they navigate the tightening financial environment.
Evergrande, listed in Hong Kong, has been grappling with the complexities of settling a restructuring plan. Progress was stalled in September when the company failed to proceed with a refinancing of its overseas debt, which was complicated by an unspecified regulatory inquiry. This delay has further complicated the timeline for recovery efforts and has raised new concerns among stakeholders.
Although the liquidation hearing in Hong Kong has faced multiple adjournments, Judge Linda Chan provided Evergrande with “one last opportunity” in October to present a new restructuring proposal. She cautioned that if the company fails to do so, it is “very likely” to face a winding-up order, increasing the urgency of the situation for all involved.
The ongoing negotiations reflect the limited options available to international creditors seeking to recover a portion of their investments, as indicated by sources familiar with the discussions. The winding-up petition may serve as a strategic “negotiating tool” aimed at compelling a more favorable restructuring agreement, highlighting the intricate dynamics at play.
Recently, Evergrande proposed a debt-to-equity swap that would provide creditors with minority stakes in the company and two of its Hong Kong-listed subsidiaries. However, no agreement has been reached thus far, as some creditors have expressed a desire for majority stakes, complicating the negotiation process and reflecting diverse interests among stakeholders.
A significant hurdle in any potential agreement is the involvement of Hui Ka Yan, the company’s chairman and founder. Hui has been subjected to “mandatory measures” by Chinese authorities due to suspicions of involvement in “illegal activities.” This situation, disclosed in a stock market filing, raises concerns about his ability to engage in and approve any restructuring deals, given his significant 60 percent stake in the company at the end of 2022, as per corporate filings.
Insiders have expressed skepticism regarding the viability of further restructuring efforts, indicating that “there is little meaning now” in pursuing new plans under the current circumstances. “It’s challenging to attract investors with a less favorable deal, and more critically, it’s difficult to locate the individual responsible for finalizing these agreements,” they noted, underscoring the complexities of the situation.
