Throughout an antitrust trial over its Northeast Alliance partnership with JetBlue, American Airways has argued that the one manner it may well compete in New York is by teaming up with the smaller airline. The issue, American says, is that it’s not possible to get entry to new “slots” that permit it to schedule extra departures and arrivals from the capacity-controlled New York airports.

Whereas that is true for all airways, American is within the distinctive place of getting given away slots it beforehand held within the early 2010s as a part of its merger with US Airways.

But it surely seems that American nonetheless had extra slots to make use of, and will have had a reasonably stronger presence in New York — if solely it hadn’t forgotten about them.

Need extra airline-specific information? Join TPG’s free biweekly Aviation e-newsletter.

In 2019, the Federal Aviation Administration reclaimed seven slots from American Airways, chief industrial officer Vasu Raja confirmed in U.S. District Courtroom in Boston on Friday, after an audit discovered that American was underutilizing the coveted use-it-or-lose-it spots.

The rationale for the underutilization, Raja mentioned, was that within the aftermath of the merger with US Airways, the slots have been merely forgotten about.

“Accounting and mixing slots after the merger was a guide course of,” Raja, who used to primarily handle the airline’s community, mentioned. “There is no good motive, and I am a bit of beside myself that it occurred.”

“It was for the worst of causes,” he conceded. “It makes us sound utterly ridiculous.”

Dialogue of the slots got here throughout a dialogue about American’s pre-pandemic — and pre-Northeast Alliance — plans to develop and reshape its service at Boston Logan Worldwide Airport and John F. Kennedy Worldwide Airport, two of the airports coated by the Northeast Alliance (the others are LaGuardia Airport and Newark Liberty Worldwide Airport).

In a Feb. 5, 2019, electronic mail response to Brent Alex, a regulatory affairs director at American Airways, Raja confirmed that they’d agreed to give up the slots to the FAA as a result of they weren’t being absolutely used.

Associated: The little-understood authorities rule that enables airways to dominate sure airports

“Do not solid this as we ‘misplaced’ slots,” Raja wrote. “We did not use all of our slots for years to the purpose that nobody knew our true baseline.”

Within the electronic mail proven in courtroom, Raja wrote that the airline thought it had 216 slots after shedding the seven, whereas the FAA thought that it had 200. In the long run, the 2 agreed to permit American to carry onto 210 slots.

The “slot” system governs takeoffs and landings on the world’s busiest airports as a mechanism to control visitors stream and keep away from each harmful overcrowding and anti-competitive actions — suppose “hoarding” — by some airways. Within the U.S., three airports — JFK, LaGuardia and Ronald Reagan Washington Nationwide Airport in Washington, D.C., are slot managed, whereas a fourth — Newark — is taken into account “schedule managed” as an alternative, which is the same system with a number of variations.

Until an airport builds a brand new runway or in any other case finds a approach to improve capability — additional optimizing air visitors management patterns, as an example — the variety of slots is finite, and all slots are ruled by the FAA. Every slot represents one takeoff or touchdown — a “slot pair” would signify certainly one of every, or a round-trip flight.

American has mentioned that it wants the alliance with JetBlue to be able to compete within the New York market, which is primarily dominated by Delta and United. JetBlue was the biggest airline at JFK within the 12-month interval ending in July 2022, in response to the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, however has restricted potential to develop as a consequence of a considerably smaller route community than the legacy airways.

By combining JetBlue’s slots at JFK (and American’s at LaGuardia) with American’s broader community, the 2 airways have argued that they are often formidable opponents in opposition to the Delta-United entrenchment.

Whereas the alliance was cleared within the waning days of the Trump administration, the Division of Justice sued in 2021, alleging that by codesharing and collaborating to run complementary route networks by means of New York and Boston, the alliance between the 2 would “remove important competitors between American and JetBlue that has led to decrease fares and better high quality service for customers touring to and from these airports.”

Accomplice progress: American provides 6 new routes as a part of Northeast Alliance tie-up with JetBlue

The airways, nevertheless, say that within the 18 months because the alliance was authorized, fares haven’t elevated and customers have had entry to higher selections.

The alliance creates one single, stronger and “related competitor out of two weak ones,” Richard Schwed, a lawyer from Shearman & Sterling representing JetBlue, argued in his opening, citing 50 new nonstop routes which have been added to or from New York or Boston because the alliance was fashioned, 90 nonstop routes with elevated capability, 17 new worldwide routes coated by the alliance, and a greater than 17% improve in complete capability on the routes coated by the alliance.

The trial started in U.S. District Courtroom in Boston on Tuesday and is anticipated to run for as much as three weeks. JetBlue CEO Robin Hayes testified earlier within the week, and testimony is anticipated from American Airways CEO Robert Isom and former CEO Doug Parker. Different stakeholders, together with community planners for the airways and former government Scott Laurence, who architected the alliance on the JetBlue facet, are additionally anticipated to testify. A call from U.S. District Choose Leo Sorokin might take weeks or months.

TPG is reporting from the U.S. District Courtroom in Boston, so keep tuned for the newest on the trial.